Quick answer: Choose the pill if you’re fine with a daily routine, the patch if you’d rather change it once a week, or the ring if you want something you swap only every three weeks or every month (if you want to skip monthly bleeds). If you’re sensitive to estrogen, keep in mind that the patch delivers the most of the three (a progestin-only pill avoids it entirely), and if you want to skip periods, the pill and ring make that the easiest. Either way, Pandia Health’s doctors review your health history and concerns to help you choose the method that’s best for you.
| Pill | Patch | Ring | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How often | Every day | Once a week (3 weeks on, 1 off), or change weekly for 12 weeks, then take 1 week off to bleed, and repeat | Every 3 weeks (in for 3, out for 1), or change every 4 weeks or every month |
| Effectiveness in preventing pregnancy (typical use) | About 93% | About 93% | About 93% |
| Can you skip periods? | Yes, easily | Possible, but only for 12 weeks at a time | Yes, easily |
| Main trade-off | Easy to forget the daily dose | Highest estrogen; can irritate skin | A sexual partner may feel it during vaginal sex (about a 1 in 100 chance it bothers them) |
What our doctors recommend
Pandia Health’s doctors usually suggest a hormonal IUD or implant first if you are most concerned with preventing pregnancy, because these long-acting methods are the most effective (they beat tubal ligation and vasectomy, respectively). If you’d rather not use an invasive option, that’s fine.
The pill, patch and ring use essentially the same hormones (ethinyl estradiol and progestin). Our CEO/co-founder Dr. Sophia Yen points out two differences. The patch gives you more estrogen, which can raise the risk of blood clots, so it isn’t right for everyone. The patch also should not be used if your BMI is 30 or greater because of the risk of blood clots, and it doesn’t work as well at that BMI. The pill comes in 40+ formulations, so there’s more room to find one that suits you. Whichever birth control method you pick, you can always switch if you don’t like it.
Who should avoid estrogen-based birth control
The pill (combined), patch and ring all contain estrogen. Your doctor will most likely steer you toward an estrogen-free option if you:
- Smoke and are 35 or older
- Have had a blood clot, or have a clotting disorder
- Have high blood pressure (learn more about birth control and blood pressure)
What’s the takeaway?
Now that you’ve heard a bit about my experience, it’s time to explore the options on your own.
Being that every individual’s body is different, you may notice different responses to each type of birth control – what works for one person may not work for others. At the end of the day, you know your body best. Don’t be afraid to advocate for yourself.
Dr. Yen’s thoughts about the pill, patch, and ring:
Our CEO & co-founder, Dr. Yen is an expert on all things birth control. You can find her thoughts on the pill, patch, and ring below:
In general, the doctors at Pandia Health recommend that people with uteri consider long-acting reversible contraceptives (i.e. the IUD or implant) before the pill, patch, and ring because they are more effective. That being said, if you don’t like the idea of having something in your uterus or arm, then you should absolutely consider the other options.
The pill, the patch, and the ring are essentially the same drugs. However, the ring and the patch are limited in terms of choices on the market, while there are 40+ different pill options. Additionally, the patch may not be recommended for all individuals, as its higher dose of estrogen may lead to an increased risk of developing blood clots. On the other hand, the pill and the ring may be prescribed to any individual. A huge perk of these methods is that they allow you to decide when and if you get your period.
Regardless of which birth control method you use, note that you are not locked in forever. Make sure to communicate openly and honestly with your doctor to ensure that they can provide the appropriate care.
How can Pandia Health help?
At Pandia Health, our goal is to provide as many individuals as possible with affordable birth control. If you live in the US, you can sign up for our FREE delivery service. Once you enter some basic information into our online form, you can sit back and let our Patient Care Advisors do the rest. From there, you can #SkipTheTrip to the pharmacy and enjoy getting your birth control delivered right to your mailbox.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are intended to inform and induce conversation. They are the views of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of Pandia Health. This article is not, nor is it intended to be, a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
